obietrice Posted May 26 Share Posted May 26 I am in a 12 team Dynasty league. Do I make this trade or stay put. For 2023 I also have picks: 2.01, 2.02, 2.07, 3.07, 4.07, 5.07, 6.07 I was offered: Give: JK Dobbins Get: 2023 pick 1.09, and 2024 mid 2nd pick My Team: QB - Tua, Goff, Howell, Trask RB - Dobbins, J. Williams, D. Cook, Perine, Foreman, J. Cook, P. Strong, J. Ford WR - Waddle, K. Allen, Toney, Thielen, M. Thomas, T. Patrick, Hardman TE - Ertz, Everett, Likely Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
roscobangs Posted May 26 Share Posted May 26 14 hours ago, obietrice said: I am in a 12 team Dynasty league. Do I make this trade or stay put. For 2023 I also have picks: 2.01, 2.02, 2.07, 3.07, 4.07, 5.07, 6.07 I was offered: Give: JK Dobbins Get: 2023 pick 1.09, and 2024 mid 2nd pick My Team: QB - Tua, Goff, Howell, Trask RB - Dobbins, J. Williams, D. Cook, Perine, Foreman, J. Cook, P. Strong, J. Ford WR - Waddle, K. Allen, Toney, Thielen, M. Thomas, T. Patrick, Hardman TE - Ertz, Everett, Likely This is an OK offer. After looking at your team, it looks like you have a few assets that are expiring soon... It might be time to consider re-tooling. On the other hand, in non-SF the value of these rookies fall off a cliff after the 1.06. If this guy you are trading with is competing, the 1.09 is worth almost nothing to him in the short term. This probably isn't helpful but earlier this offseason I traded Swift for the 1.09, but it was in a SF. So I will end up getting one of the top WR's. In non-SF, you are probably looking at taking a Mayer or Kinkaid. I think I would end up declining this offer. Maybe you flip him Dalvin for a 2024 pick or something. Might be worth waiting to send that one because Dalvin's value might spike if he gets picked up by the Dolphins or something. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Boudewijn Posted May 28 Share Posted May 28 On 5/26/2023 at 8:22 PM, roscobangs said: On the other hand, in non-SF the value of these rookies fall off a cliff after the 1.06. If this guy you are trading with is competing, the 1.09 is worth almost nothing to him in the short term. It's superflex, but I agree nonetheless that this trade wouldn't help much. Topicstarter: I would consider a complete rebuild. You will find it hard to compete with this team - you won't be last, but you also can't really expect to win with this team. But Dobby is one of your few young usable guys (with Waddle and Javonte (?) Williams), and you shouldn't give him away for a mere 1.09. Start selling especially the older guys and focus on having a solid basis of QBs and WRs. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Big Nate Posted May 29 Share Posted May 29 16 hours ago, Boudewijn said: It's superflex, but I agree nonetheless that this trade wouldn't help much. Topicstarter: I would consider a complete rebuild. You will find it hard to compete with this team - you won't be last, but you also can't really expect to win with this team. But Dobby is one of your few young usable guys (with Waddle and Javonte (?) Williams), and you shouldn't give him away for a mere 1.09. Start selling especially the older guys and focus on having a solid basis of QBs and WRs. I agree with this in that he should think of a rebuild. I'd be trading Allen, Thielen and M. Thomas at the start of the season as soon as they produce. All getting old but hopefully you can sell them to a team who is competing and needs some WRs. I'd also trade D. Cook and Foreman - same deal: probably have to wait until the season when they are playing well after a big game or two and their value goes up. Try to get some young WRs and draft picks. As for Dobbins the 1.09 and a mid 24 second is very close to OK value (assuming SuperFlex). I think I prefer the Dobbins side right now but Dobbins doesn't help you rebuild if that makes sense (he's going to get you points when you want to try to get your first pick as close to 1.03 or lower in 24). For the trade 1.09 isn't a bad spot as one of the 4 WRs could fall to that spot (Johnson or Flowers). Flipping Dobbins for a young WR + a second isn't too bad. Basically re-rolling Dobbins into a young WR. I'm not the biggest Johnson fan but there are rumblings Williams still isn't healthy and they are desperate for passing options in this offense. QJ could get a TON of YAC even if his hands are a bit suspect. It would be nice to get more but I'm not sure that is possible at this point. If you decide to keep him and trade him midseason could you get more than a first + a second? Probably not. Maybe 2 seconds or a third if you are lucky. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
League_Champion Posted May 29 Share Posted May 29 Keep Dobbins, he's in for a career year. You can always maximize his value mod-season. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.